Red Card Reversal Sparks Outrage as Inter Miami’s Maxi Falcón Cleared to Face Pumas
In a decision that has ignited debate across MLS circles, Inter Miami defender Maxi Falcón has been cleared to play against Pumas UNAM after his red card was shockingly rescinded. The Uruguayan center back, who was ejected in Miami’s previous match for a rough challenge, now finds himself back in the lineup—leaving fans and analysts questioning the integrity of the league’s disciplinary process.
Falcón’s red card, shown in the 64th minute of a tense match last week, was widely seen as justified at the time. Replays showed a studs-up lunge—typically an automatic dismissal under FIFA guidelines. Yet just days later, MLS officials overturned the call after a so-called “thorough review,” citing “insufficient evidence of violent conduct.”
Critics are crying foul.
“This feels like a decision influenced more by marketing than merit,” said former MLS referee and ESPN analyst Paul Atkinson. “Inter Miami, with Messi sidelined and ratings dipping, needed their next big-name defender on the pitch. The reversal sets a dangerous precedent.”
Pumas fans, set to face Inter Miami in the Leagues Cup clash, are especially outraged. The Mexican club released a statement questioning the fairness of the decision and hinting at possible bias toward high-profile U.S. teams.
“Rules should apply equally, regardless of the crest on your shirt,” the statement read.
Supporters of Falcón, however, argue that the original red was harsh. Inter Miami’s interim coach labeled the tackle “firm but fair” and praised the league for “correcting a clear officiating error.” Still, with no public release of the full review details or officiating audio, transparency remains in short supply.
This incident comes amid growing criticism that MLS bends its rules for marquee clubs, particularly Inter Miami, who have drawn international attention since Lionel Messi’s arrival. Whether Falcón’s reinstatement was justice or favoritism, one thing is clear: controversy now clouds what should have been a straightforward football match.
All eyes will be on Sunday’s game—not just for the goals, but for the fallout.
