Shock in Provo: Jake Retzlaff’s Stunning BYU U-Turn Sparks Confusion, Ends in Exit
What was first reported as a miraculous change of heart has instead turned into a confusing and unfortunate chapter in BYU football history. Jake Retzlaff, the talented quarterback who helped lead BYU through a strong 2024 season, was initially rumored to have reversed his decision to transfer—signing an extension to remain with the Cougars. However, those claims turned out to be untrue.
In reality, Retzlaff officially withdrew from BYU in July 2025 after facing a likely suspension due to an Honor Code violation, ending his tenure with the program.
Rumors of a Recommitment
The story began when fringe sports websites circulated dramatic headlines claiming that Retzlaff had changed course, backing out of the NCAA transfer portal and agreeing to stay at BYU with a contract extension. The reports mentioned secret meetings with coaches, an upgraded NIL package, and a renewed commitment to the program.
Fans were stunned—in a good way. If true, this would have been a major win for BYU’s future. Retzlaff had started 13 games in 2024, throwing for nearly 3,000 yards and 20 touchdowns, while also rushing for 500+ yards. The Cougars went 11-2 and won the Alamo Bowl under his leadership.
Unfortunately, those rumors were soon debunked.
The Real Story: Legal Issues and Honor Code Trouble
Retzlaff’s departure was likely tied to legal and Honor Code challenges. A civil lawsuit accusing him of sexual assault from an incident in 2023 was filed, then dismissed in June 2025. During the legal proceedings, Retzlaff admitted to having consensual premarital sex—something that violates BYU’s strict Honor Code.
As a result, he was reportedly facing a suspension of up to seven games.
Faced with this reality, Retzlaff decided to step away. On July 11, he announced on Instagram that he was officially withdrawing from BYU, saying the decision came after much prayer and reflection. BYU Athletics confirmed his departure.
Coach Sitake’s Response and Next Steps
At Big 12 Media Days, BYU head coach Kalani Sitake respectfully declined to speak in detail about Retzlaff’s situation. He said the quarterback had chosen to speak for himself and that the team was moving forward with other options under center.
With Retzlaff gone, the BYU quarterback room is now wide open. The battle will likely come down to transfers McCae Hillstead (from Utah State), Treyson Bourguet (from Western Michigan), and incoming grad transfer Bear Bachmeier (from Stanford).
Conclusion: A Story of Lost Potential
Jake Retzlaff’s story at BYU is one of both promise and disruption. His on-field potential was undeniable, and his leadership helped BYU thrive in 2024. But off-field issues, legal complications, and Honor Code violations brought his time in Provo to an abrupt end.
What was falsely billed as a dramatic recommitment turned out to be a final chapter. Retzlaff is gone—and BYU now looks to the future with a reshuffled quarterback competition and hard lessons learned.
Would you like this turned into a newsletter article, blog post, or social media summary?
