Five Bold Coaching Candidates to Replace Coach Kalani Sitake as Head Coach for BYU
In a stunning twist that’s rocked Cougar Nation, BYU has announced it is parting ways with head coach Kalani Sitake after nearly a decade at the helm. Sitake, a BYU alumnus and the first Tongan head coach in FBS history, brought heart, pride, and memorable victories to Provo, including a dominant 11-win season in 2020. But after back-to-back disappointing Big 12 campaigns and mounting pressure from boosters and alumni, BYU is headed in a new direction. The question now is: Who’s next?
Here are five bold—but entirely plausible—candidates to take over in Provo:
1. Jay Hill – BYU Associate Head Coach & Defensive Coordinator
Hill is the most logical internal hire. Since joining BYU in 2023, he’s revitalized a previously porous defense with aggression and discipline. His track record at Weber State—where he turned a struggling FCS program into a powerhouse—shows he knows how to build. Hill understands the unique culture and expectations at BYU and would provide continuity during a potentially volatile transition.
2. Andy Reid – Kansas City Chiefs Head Coach
Yes, it’s a moonshot. But it’s not pure fantasy. Reid, a BYU alum and close friend of the university, has openly mused about finishing his coaching career where it began. With multiple Super Bowl rings and a Hall of Fame résumé, Reid would immediately elevate BYU’s national profile. If he’s ready to retire from the NFL grind, this could be his legacy move.
3. Aaron Roderick – BYU Offensive Coordinator
Roderick has been the architect of BYU’s most explosive offenses in recent years, mentoring NFL-caliber QBs like Zach Wilson and Jaren Hall. While recent inconsistencies have raised questions, many inside the program believe he’s ready to take the reins. Promoting Roderick would maintain offensive continuity and reward loyalty and development from within.
4. Ken Niumatalolo – Former Navy Head Coach
Another intriguing name with strong LDS ties and a wealth of head coaching experience. Niumatalolo spent 15 years leading Navy, navigating service academy restrictions and producing consistent winners. His disciplined, character-first approach mirrors BYU’s ethos, and with time away from the game, he may be ready for a fresh challenge with a program closer to his faith and family.
5. Bronco Mendenhall – Former BYU and Virginia Head Coach
Could a homecoming be in the cards? Mendenhall left BYU in 2015 under unusual circumstances but with a solid record and the respect of many in Provo. After stepping down from Virginia in 2021, he’s rested, recharged, and still passionate about coaching. A Mendenhall reunion would be a shocker—but one the fan base might embrace if framed as a redemption story.
As BYU stares down the future of Big 12 competition and playoff aspirations, the next head coach must bring vision, toughness, and a deep understanding of what makes Cougar football special. These candidates, while varied in background and pedigree, all carry the DNA of bold leadership—and that’s exactly what BYU needs now.
