Kirk Herbstreit, a former Ohio State football player and one of the most prominent sports analysts in the country, has long been associated with the Buckeyes. His deep ties to the university, including his role as an ESPN college football analyst, have made him a beloved figure among Ohio State fans. However, over the years, especially during his career as a commentator, Herbstreit has faced significant criticism from some fans for his impartiality when calling games involving Ohio State.
The “traitor” accusations stem from his role in providing objective analysis, even when it may go against Ohio State’s interests or performance. Herbstreit has earned a reputation for not being afraid to criticize his alma mater when they underperform, which has not always been well received by the fanbase. Some fans expected his commentary to always align with Ohio State’s success, but instead, he has often been a fair and balanced voice, holding teams to a higher standard, regardless of affiliation.
Further complicating the situation is Herbstreit’s family, including his children, who have made headlines for their own athletic achievements. His son, Jake, for example, committed to play quarterback for Clemson, a major rival of Ohio State. This decision amplified the “traitor” sentiment among some Ohio State fans who felt that Herbstreit, having been such a prominent figure at Ohio State, should have steered his son toward joining the Buckeyes. The idea of his son playing for a rival program, particularly Clemson, fueled the belief that the Herbstreit family was turning its back on Ohio State.
Herbstreit, to his credit, has always emphasized the importance of supporting his children’s choices, regardless of where they choose to play. However, the situation raised uncomfortable questions about loyalty, particularly in the highly competitive world of college football, where fans often expect unwavering allegiance to their schools, even from former players and their families. His son’s decision to join a rival program, coupled with Herbstreit’s commentary on various Ohio State games, has stirred emotions, with some viewing it as a betrayal.
Despite this, it’s essential to understand that Kirk Herbstreit’s role as an analyst requires him to be objective and fair. His commentary is not meant to pander to any fanbase but to provide insightful analysis to a nationwide audience. His son’s decision to attend Clemson is an individual choice, and like any father, Herbstreit has respected his son’s decision.
The “traitor” label placed on the Herbstreit family, therefore, reflects the intense loyalty and passion that college football fans feel toward their teams. It also highlights the difficulties faced by public figures in maintaining their personal and professional lives in the glare of the spotlight. While some may continue to criticize, Kirk Herbstreit remains a respected figure in sports commentary, proving that even amid criticism, his commitment to fairness and family stands strong.